Adam Resurrected: A Roundtable

By David D'Arcy

Adam ResurrectedIn Adam Resurrected, Paul Schrader's new film which premiered at Telluride in September, a psychiatric institute for Holocaust survivors in the Negev Desert becomes a stage for the enactment of a painful tangle of memories. These walking (and crawling) wounded are anything but pious. The sanitarium is also the place for an encounter between a Jewish cabaret clown (Jeff Goldblum) who survived Auschwitz while playing a dog for the camp boss (Willem Dafoe) and a teenage boy, David (Tudor Rapiteanu), who believes he is a dog.

The film is adapted from the 1968 Israeli novel by Yoram Kaniuk, which was received coldly in Israel for its seemingly irreverent treatment of the Holocaust with a cast of mad survivors and its examination of an odd case of a clown's compromise in the face of death. The book developed an international reputation after Susan Sontag gave it a glowing endorsement, which helped turn Adam Resurrected into a modern classic in the comic-grotesque strain of The Tin Drum and Slaughterhouse-Five. Filmmakers have been trying to put it on the screen ever since, among them Charlie Chaplin and Orson Welles.

This adaptation, which still lacks a US distributor, is written by the young Israeli-trained screenwriter Noah Stollman. Critics, so far, have not been kind (including Israelis), although I am an exception - see my review in Screen. You'll be hearing more about the novel, regardless of when the film finally gets a theatrical release. A new edition is due out soon.

What follows is a conversation about adaptation and its challenges among Paul Schrader, the novelist Yoram Kaniuk, producer Ehud Bleiberg, and myself at the Haifa International Film Festival in Israel, where Adam Resurrected saw its Israeli premiere.
 
David D'Arcy: What's the challenge of adapting a book for the screen?

Paul Schrader: Well, I've also adapted The Last Temptation of Christ, by Nikos Kazantzakis, and that was as difficult as adapting Adam Resurrected. I did Mosquito Coast for Peter Weir, and I did Affliction for myself - and I directed Ian McEwan's Comfort of Strangers, and something else out there, too.

Look, every book is different. Every book is a different challenge. Sometimes they're easy, where the narrative of a book just folds into two hours. That was the case with Affliction. And sometimes they're extremely difficult. Sometimes you're out to capture the book itself, and sometimes you're not. Sometimes you want to do something different than the book does. Sometimes, as in the case of Last Temptation, there were maybe five or six different scripts inside that book. You had to go inside the book, dig out all the various ways you could go, and pick the one you want to do that means the most to you. With Adam, I did not adapt it. It was written by Noah Stollman, an American who studied here at Sam Spiegel [School of Film and Television in Jerusalem]. One of the fierce challenges of this particular book is that it does not lend itself to realistic translation.

It's not quite magic realism, but it's not quite realism either. There's a lot of internal monologues in it, the chronology is completely scattered, the ending of the book is about two-thirds of the way through, characters have doppelgangers who may or may not be real. There's a second Adam called Herbert. The character of Shasta, played by Hana Laszlo, has a twin sister who may or may not be her at any given time.

Adam Resurrected

I'm a huge fan of Yoram's book, so I have to preface all my remarks by saying that we made a very good adaptation in this film, but we cannot approach the greatness of the book. The greatness of the book is defined by its literary quality, by its words. When a book is really a literary masterpiece, rather than a narrative masterpiece, you can never quite do it justice, because it is what it is. You are never really going to do The Sound and the Fury or Lolita. You can get pretty close, but you can't really nail a book whose very language is its greatness. The reason that Philip Roth's books have failed to make good films is because he writes about despicable characters who are redeemed by language. When you translate them into film, you have despicable characters, but you don't have language.

D'Arcy: Yoram, given what Paul just said about the difficulty of adapting any novel and the difficulty of adapting this novel, were you skeptical or wary of anyone trying to make a film about this book? And Paul was not the first person to try it.

Yoram Kaniuk: The idea for this book is that first it was an idea for a movie. I gave it to Lewis Milestone, who was a very famous director. I started to write it when I was still a painter, so I saw it all the time. I saw, with my eyes, every thing in this book. It took me ten years to write it. I saw it lend itself to be adapted, but if you adapted that book, it would be a 16-hour movie.

Paul captured the essence of this book. I didn't read the script. I didn't want to read the script. I went to a few days of screenings, and the only words I herd were "cut, cut." I finally saw it in a theater in Tel Aviv, and I was a bit nervous, but it is exactly the essence of the book. I think that Paul, and Noah, and of course Jeff - Jeff was not the actor I imagined; I thought more of a German Jew in the role. The idea of a man who is a genius, but all he can do is be a clown, is one that I had seen many times in my life. When Jeff is talking, and he's talking about his childhood, it's me that he's talking about. So, in a way, I think Paul adapted me, and not only the book.
 

Comments

Thanks for every other

Thanks for every other informative site. The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such an ideal means? I have a venture that I’m just now operating on, and I have been on the look out for such information.

Penitishop.com Jual Almamater Terbaik

Maidaniipancakedurian.com Distributor Resmi Pancake Durian, Oleh Oleh Khas Medan

Anizan Google Adsense Alternative

There are some elements that

There are some elements that are true to my life. Being an actor in Taiwan, there's not that much work and - because the industry doesn't really create enough films for them to subsist financially - I did play the stock market. Even as I was shooting this film, I was playing the stock market and - when I was making a lot of money - it showed on camera. But then when I wasn't making enough, it likewise affected the tone of the film.

Thanks for the information

Very informative article and good content, cheers for sharing this with your readers. I have saved this article and will tell all of my mates about this.
Link Alternatif Juara Poker
Juara Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Live Dingdong Online Bro Togel
Link Alternatif Elang Poker
Cara Menghitung Toto SGP by Singaporepools.info
Kelemahan Rumus Konversi Lama Toto SGP
Inilah Keakuratan Rumus Konversi Baru Togel SGP 2014
Prediksi Togel Hongkong Hari Ini 27 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Taiwan Hari Ini 27 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Singapore Hari Ini 27 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel China Hari Ini 27 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Sydney Hari Ini 27 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Cambodia Hari Ini 27 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Hongkong Hari Ini 26 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Taiwan Hari Ini 26 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Singapore Hari Ini 26 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel China Hari Ini 26 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Sydney Hari Ini 26 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Cambodia Hari Ini 26 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Hongkong Hari Ini 25 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Taiwan Hari Ini 25 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Singapore Hari Ini 25 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel China Hari Ini 25 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Sydney Hari Ini 25 Oktober 2014
Prediksi Togel Cambodia Hari Ini 25 Oktober 2014
Link Alternatif Juara Poker
Juara Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Live Dingdong Online Bro Togel
Link Alternatif Elang Poker
Cara Menghitung Toto SGP by Singaporepools.info
Kelemahan Rumus Konversi Lama Toto SGP
Inilah Keakuratan Rumus Konversi Baru Togel SGP 2014
Perbedaan Rumus Konversi Baru dan Lama | Togel Singapura
Rumus Konversi Togel Singapura Terbaru 2014
Result Togel Singapura menjadi 49 Bola Kamis 9 Oktober 2014
Cara Hitung Togel Singapura | Konversi Togel Singapura
Cara Membuka Situs Poker Online Yang di Blokir
Live Dingdong 36D hanya ada di BROtogel.com
Link Alamat Alternatif Sbobet - Situs Lain Sbobet
Google.co.id Kena Hack | Poker Online Indonesia
Link Alternatif Poker Club88
Alamat Alternatif Ace Poker 99 | Poker Ace99
Alamat Alternatif Lotus4d
Link Alternatif Dewa Togel
Link Alternatif Jayabet
Alamat Alamat Afa Togel
Alamat Alternatif Totobet
Alamat Alternatif Rgo Togel
Jaya Poker Lebih Fresh dan Mantap dengan Wajah Baru!!!
Alamat Alternatif Jaya Togel
Alamat Alternatif Dewa Togel
Alamat Alternatif Togel Cc
Alamat Alternatif Eyang Togel
Alamat Alternatif 8Togel
Poker Club88 | Game Judi Poker Online
Poker Ace99 | Game Judi Poker Online
Alamat Alternatif Afa Poker
Alamat Alternatif Texaspoker Cc
Jaya Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Batik Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Poker Boya | Game Judi Poker Online
Texaspoker.cc | Game Judi Poker Online
Apakah Rgo Poker Pakai Robot atau ada admin yang bermain?
Alamat Alternatif Totojitu
Alamat Alternatif Kaskus
Alamat Alternatif Horas Poker
Alamat Alternatif Dewa Poker
Alamat Alternatif Afa Poker
Gitar Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Alamat Alternatif Gitar Poker
Video Rgo Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Rgo Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Video Gitar Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Alamat Alternatif Rgo Poker
Alamat Alternatif Batik Poker
Alamat Alternatif Eyang Poker
Alamat Alternatif Jaya Poker
Game Judi Poker Online - Referral Poker Boya
Game Judi Poker Online - Poker Online Indonesia Terpercaya
Afa Poker | Poker Online Indonesia
Alamat Alternatif Poker Cc
Kesulitan Mengakses Situs Warung Poker
Judi Poker Online Indonesia
Permainan Judi Poker Online
Gagal Login Warung Poker
Alamat Alternatif Resmi Warung Poker
Cara Bermain Judi Poker Online
Situs Online Poker
Judi Poker Online Terpercaya
Bandar Poker Online
Cara Bermain Poker Indonesia
Cara Deposit Poker Online
Cara Agar Menang Bermain Poker
Game Poker Online Bca
Game Judi Online Poker
Alamat Alternatif Poker Boya
Alamat Alternatif Warung Poker
Panduan Bermain Poker
Situs Judi Poker Online Terbaik
Solusi Nawala Internet Positif - Game Judi Poker Online
Website Poker Online Indonesia - Prediksi Roma VS Sampdoria 10 Januari 2014
Permainan Poker Uang Asli
Situs Judi Poker Online - Prediksi Real Madrid Vs Osasuna 10 Januari 2014
Game Judi Poker Online
Game Judi Poker Online - Judi Poker Online Terpercaya
Situs Poker Online Uang Asli
Poker Online Indonesia
9 Situs Poker Terbaik
Kumpulan Alamat Alternatif Poker Online Indonesia

new balance outlet

It looks like the US is giving New Balance's 576 model some well-deserved love, as here we get a look at the upcoming Made in USA "Camo" Pack http://www.newbalancestorelocations.com of the oft-produced UK sneaker option.The low-top silhouette is presented in a pair of colorways, one grey and one green, each noting suede new balance us upper construction. The camouflage detailing has been applied at the collar, the toe box and at the heel, as leather N branding then new balance minimus reflects alongside on each.Get a look at each camo entry from NB above and be sure to check back with us for specifics new balance shoes for women on the Made in USA 576 tandem.Well, at the time I was the number 1 pick coming out in '82, I had new balance shoes a lot of choices, but New Balance was very attractive to me because they were willing to make me the highest-paid player to new balance have a sneaker contract. And also, the product was new to basketball so once I saw the product was a really good product new balance 998 and a really good shoe,- like the Mercedes of sneakers, I was excited about being with a company that I knew could match new balance outlet what I needed as far as performance and durability. They asked me a variety of questions as to what I wanted in a new balance outlet shoe, how I wanted it to perform, and then they built a shoe around that. It was just a great relationship-New Balance was new balance shoes for women all about family and that's what I felt right away. I just didn't want to be a number. I wanted to be a http://www.newbalancesaleinc.com part of something special, and they did special things. You know they would much rather have you Russ, run commercials with you, or new balance a banker, a handicapped person, than to have a big official new balance store major star, so that was very attractive to me. Even though sneaker culture is dominated by guys, there are plenty of females who actually wear sneakers that probably have just as much heat as the fellas.New Balance has kept its ear to new balance 997 the streets and recently featured three popular female sneakerheads in a lookbook to debut its first-ever "Elite Edition" for women. Ericka Gilbert (@DamnnEricka), new balance sarasota Ivelisse Cassas (@Soledevida) and Brittany Sklar (@Britta_Ruth920) sport the New Balance 580 "Elite Edition" in three upcoming vibrant colorways. The collection is a new balance 990 nod to the woven patterns in tapestry and each 580 comes equipped with woven paneling, pig suede, mesh, and a speckled print midsole.The new balance women's New Balance 580 "Elite Edition" will be available in all three colorways-green, grey, and black-on July 1 at NewBalance.com for $100.The new balance outlet holidays are full of pies, roasts, and expanding guts. It's hard not to put on a few pounds when Christmas and New Year's new balance store come around. While it's easy to switch pants from a 32 to a 34, buying a size 10.5 instead of a 10 doesn't new balance 608 work the same way.Gaining weight makes it harder to reach down and tie sneakers, it also makes people lounge around more as they new balance logo consume the platters that relatives brought over. The remedy for this is sneakers that are comfortable, supportive, and easy to get in and new balance sneakers for women out of. Whether it be a pair of Velcro skate shoes or sneakers with no laces at all, here are The 10 Best new balance golf shoes men Sneakers To Wear While Gaining Weight During the Holidays.What began as a personal project years back has since turned into a complete new balance 574 exploration into the archives of the 1500 model from New Balance. Matt Kyte of Australia set out to illustrate every colorway of the new balance shoes sneaker that has ever been released.Those NBs recently had the opportunity to sit down with Matt, hear a bit of his story, and new balance store also check out some illustrations."When I started on this project years back the 1500 was the crown jewel of the retro New Balance new balance shoes catalogue. Since then things have changed but I still think that the shoe itself when presented in a good colourway with the correct new balance 996 aggressive shape is one of the greatest shoes created."

divergence cash free credit

divergence cash free credit reports and scores smart markets information

Thanks for every other

Thanks for every other informative site. The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such an ideal means? I have a venture that I’m just now operating on, and I have been on the look out for such information.
Jasa Iklan & Menambah Like Fanpage Facebook Ads
vcc.co.id provider vcc murah di indonesia
Maidaniipancakedurian.com Distributor Resmi Pancake Durian, Oleh Oleh Khas Medan

Game Judi Poker Online

Very informative article and good content, cheers for sharing this with your readers. I have saved this article and will tell all of my mates about this.

Cara Membuka Situs Poker Online Yang di Blokir
Live Dingdong 36D hanya ada di BROtogel.com
Link Alamat Alternatif Sbobet - Situs Lain Sbobet
Google.co.id Kena Hack | Poker Online Indonesia
Link Alternatif Poker Club88
Alamat Alternatif Ace Poker 99 | Poker Ace99
Alamat Alternatif Lotus4d
Link Alternatif Dewa Togel
Link Alternatif Jayabet
Alamat Alamat Afa Togel
Alamat Alternatif Totobet
Alamat Alternatif Rgo Togel
Jaya Poker Lebih Fresh dan Mantap dengan Wajah Baru!!!
Alamat Alternatif Jaya Togel
Alamat Alternatif Dewa Togel
Alamat Alternatif Togel Cc
Alamat Alternatif Eyang Togel
Alamat Alternatif 8Togel
Poker Club88 | Game Judi Poker Online
Poker Ace99 | Game Judi Poker Online
Alamat Alternatif Afa Poker
Alamat Alternatif Texaspoker Cc
Jaya Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Batik Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Poker Boya | Game Judi Poker Online
Texaspoker.cc | Game Judi Poker Online
Apakah Rgo Poker Pakai Robot atau ada admin yang bermain?
Alamat Alternatif Totojitu
Alamat Alternatif Kaskus
Alamat Alternatif Horas Poker
Alamat Alternatif Dewa Poker
Alamat Alternatif Afa Poker
Gitar Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Alamat Alternatif Gitar Poker
Video Rgo Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Rgo Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Video Gitar Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Alamat Alternatif Rgo Poker
Alamat Alternatif Batik Poker
Alamat Alternatif Eyang Poker
Alamat Alternatif Jaya Poker
Game Judi Poker Online - Referral Poker Boya
Game Judi Poker Online - Poker Online Indonesia Terpercaya
Afa Poker | Poker Online Indonesia
Alamat Alternatif Poker Cc
Kesulitan Mengakses Situs Warung Poker
Judi Poker Online Indonesia
Permainan Judi Poker Online
Gagal Login Warung Poker
Alamat Alternatif Resmi Warung Poker
Cara Bermain Judi Poker Online
Situs Online Poker
Judi Poker Online Terpercaya
Bandar Poker Online
Cara Bermain Poker Indonesia
Cara Deposit Poker Online
Cara Agar Menang Bermain Poker
Game Poker Online Bca
Game Judi Online Poker
Alamat Alternatif Poker Boya
Alamat Alternatif Warung Poker
Panduan Bermain Poker
Situs Judi Poker Online Terbaik
Solusi Nawala Internet Positif - Game Judi Poker Online
Website Poker Online Indonesia - Prediksi Roma VS Sampdoria 10 Januari 2014
Permainan Poker Uang Asli
Situs Judi Poker Online - Prediksi Real Madrid Vs Osasuna 10 Januari 2014
Game Judi Poker Online
Game Judi Poker Online - Judi Poker Online Terpercaya

greetings all. information

greetings all. information that I can right here is extremely useful for
me, and probably also for his friends, for excellent info I would like
to thank the, My web.  The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such an ideal means? I have a venture that I’m just now operating on, and I have been on the look out for such information.   Thanks 4 all This My site Its love true. By Dhini Carnetta Jasa SEO

Thanks for every other informative BY my site Jasa SEO.

In My kontes Seo Bismillahirrohmanirrohim

Market Location Miami Beach

Market Location Miami Beach has attracted many profitable. Main real estate, apartments for sale in Miami, the killer of the Atlantic is the highest tower. Miami Apartments in abundance Miami luxury condominium, but the economic situation stabilizes them quickly.

Thank you for sharing such an

Thank you for sharing such an informative blog article, I really appreciate your hard work and effort in writing this article. Anyway I'm also here to introduce our product, just click and follow the link below to enjoy and have a try on it. We are real and legit...

buy pinterest likes

Good day! It's my first time

Good day! It's my first time to visit here but I was totally amazed with the content of your website. It's very detailed and concise. I'm so grateful and happy that I had visited here, so much of valuable and significant ideas I've found in your website. I'll definitely be back here for updates.

Be with us to, gain soundcloud likes

Wolverine

Boyd, war nach Hause withthem kommen, weil sie sich weigerten, an einer Institution , wo die Zwillinge waren nicht willkommen bleiben . Michael Kors Handbags Stuartand Brent als ihre neuesten Vertreibung ein feiner Sattel michael kors bags Muskeln , ��berquerte fahrl?ssig . Neunzehn Jahre alt, sechs Fu? Michael Kors Outlet Store zwei Zoll gro?, der lange boneand Fest von Muskeln, mit chanel bags sonnenverbrannten Gesichtern und tief kastanienbraunen Haar , ihre Beatrice Louis Vuitton Bags Tarleton war eine vielbesch?ftigte Frau mit auf ihre H?nde nicht Louis Vuitton Outlet nur eine gro?e Baumwollplantage , ahundred Neger und acht Kinder, Authentic Louis Vuitton aber die gr??te Pferdezuchtin den Zustand als gut. Siewar j?hzornig michael kors outlet online und leicht durch die h?ufige Kratzen ihrer vier S?hne geplagt louis vuitton bags , und w?hrend keine onewas erlaubt, ein Pferd oder einen Michael Kors Outlet Sklaven zu peitschen , f��hlte sie , dass ein prada outlet lecken und wieder nicht die Jungen anyharm tun .mit F��?en getreten hatte , die traf den Zug atJonesboro . Und kurz bevor wir nach Hause kamen Louis Vuitton , hatte er trat die stabil nach unten und Halb gucci outlet online killedStrawberry , Ma alten Hengst. Als wir nach totheir kate spade unmittelbaren Situation . "Was hat deine Mutter ��ber Sie sagen gucci outlet zwei , die wieder ausgetrieben ? " Die Jungs sahen Louis Vuitton Sale unangenehm , unter Hinweis auf das Verhalten ihrer Mutter vor Louis Vuitton Handbags drei Abendessen . Zwischen den Hunden und den Pferden new balance und den Zwillingen gab es eine Verwandtschaft tiefer als die Kate Spade Bags theirconstant Kameradschaft. Sie waren alle gesund, gedanken junge Tiere , Louis Vuitton Outlet schlanke

This Text Your Ex Back review

This Text Your Ex Back review examines the Michael Fiore PDF and its ability to help you get your ex back using tiny text messages sent from your cell phone
Bundapoker.Com Agen Texas Poker Dan Domino Online Indonesia Terpercaya Gudangpoker.com Situs Judi Poker Online Terbaik Terpercaya Cipto Junaedy| Cipto Junaedy | Singgasana Hotels & Resorts pilihan akomodasi terbaik di Indonesia

suwun

Very informative article my good friend, cheers for sharing this with your readers. I have saved this article and will tell all of my mates about this.

I wish I had found out about this blog earlier; will visit back for sure! Obat Kutil Kelamin | menghilangkan kutil di kemaluan | Obat Kutil Kelamin | menghilangkan kutil di kemaluan | Obat Kutil Di kemaluan |

Oh my goodness! Awesome

Oh my goodness! Awesome article dude! Thank you so much, However I am having difficulties with your RSS. I don't know why I can't join it. Is there anyone else having similar RSS issues? Anybody who knows the solution will you kindly respond? Thanx!!

free rental agreement

BUYSOCIALNOW.COM

I am very glad to learn a lot from you this meaningful knowledge. From an article describing your unique way , we can see that you are an approachable , humorous person. Not only that, your article is rich with a lot of useful knowledge and helpful information.
how to buy soundcloud likes
-http://www.buysocialnow.com

Thank you for this great

Thank you for this great article. jersey grade ori I hope you know how to strive for the latest updates on all the time. dp bbm Another time I will visit here again. harga xenia 2014 untuk jersey jogja cuci sofa astra daihatsu

Like!!!

Very informative article my good friend, cheers for sharing this with your readers. I have saved this article and will tell all of my mates about this.

I wish I had found out about this blog earlier; will visit back for sure!

Thanks!

Check This Out
Check This Out
Check This Out

Reminder: Your payment for this invoice (5237) is due

great conteent

Figuring out how considerably

Figuring out how considerably excess weight to shed is a key aspect of that setting up.If you want to lose weight rapid, consume Slim Pro daily for 24 days and see the change in you. have a nice figure and body with Slim Pro.Buy Slim Pro –To decrease your fatness

Nice Review

I like this movie and watch on my laptop asus notebook terbaik dan favoritku. Thank's for Nais Info - Click Info

I do not like him very much.

I do not like him very much. The only movie I liked Jurassic Park First and Second which he acted pretty well. He is a good actor, but I always felt that he can do only one kind of role. He is not dynamic as Leonardo Dicaprio or Christian Bale.
tonsil and adenoid removal

* You can comment on articles

* Private messaging to others in the GreenCine community -- and more features coming soon!

* Keep apprised of happenings in the world of films festivals, independent, international, cult, classic, horror movies and more!

* As a free registered member, you can upgrade your account to a rental subscription -- or if you want a rental subscription right away, click here.