Béla Tarr and "This Process of Making"

GreenCineStaff's picture

By Jay Kuehner

"We all have a background in reality."

The following interview with Hungarian director Béla Tarr was conducted at the 2001 San Francisco International Film Festival, which presented Tarr's seventh feature, Werckmeister Harmonies (2000). While Tarr's films may warrant timeless consideration for cinephiles, the belated publishing of our conversation owes considerably to the ongoing caprices of film distribution.

If Tarr's monumental Sátántangó (1994) had a seismic effect on film discourse in general - and film practice in particular - in spite of its scarce public screenings, it is that much more lamentable that Werckmeister Harmonies, a film of more modest proportion but equally resonant, should have languished without wider release. Correcting the undeserved fate of an acknowledged master's oeuvre, Facets Multimedia has released the film on DVD as part of a campaign that has included Tarr's earlier films, Family Nest (1978), The Outsider (1981) and Prefab People (1982), with Damnation (1987) and Sátántangó apparently in the works.

Tracking down Tarr proved to be necessarily funny, as our appointment coincided with a festival party in honor of Bruce Weber. Instantly recognizable in his long leather coat and silvered mane, Tarr cuts an imposing figure more in theory than in conversation. We were joined by actor Lars Rudolph, and invaluable translation assistance was provided by Joseph Kish.

In a post-screening discussion with the audience, you defended your film against too much speculation.

If you are listening to the film, and simply watching, you will find there is little reason for speculation about the film's meaning. This is why I have said: No allegories, no metaphors, no symbols, nothing...

Meaning, you've designed the film to have no explicit political context, or that it's just difficult to pinpoint? I'm reminded of Kafka.

No, Kafka is cold. And this film is very warm. If you don't believe this, perhaps your heart isn't working. I want you to see a movie full of emotions. I want to convince you to love these people. Love Janos Valuska (Lars Rudolph), love Mrs. Eszter (Hanna Schygulla), love the 600 unemployed workers, because I am in all of them. I know, it sounds like a declaration from the 60s, but unfortunately, it's true.

When we started shooting, we never thought that it would take four years to make this film. There were several times during the shoot when we simply felt that we could not continue. We had no money, we had nothing. Maybe, I thought, it was not necessary to make this movie. But I would look at the rushes and tell myself, we must make this, because I absolutely love the people in this movie. So it's very personal.

If anyone in the film seems to love everyone, it's Valuska.

I hope so. He likes everybody because I think he understands them. He's innocent. He walks from here to there, says hello and goodbye. Yes, he's very innocent, but he's a little worried.

So maybe he doesn't understand what he's seeing when the hospital is sacked?

That's the breaking point. This, and the explosion he sees. A revolution has started, but for him, it's over. By the end, he's in a mental hospital.

That's an ambiguous scene, Valuska sitting motionless on his bed. There's light coming into the room. It almost seems... comfortable?

No, it's not comfortable. It's cold. He looks like a blocked angel, you know? There's light, but he can't move. He may never move. He's out of society, out of the system. Everything is now over, but maybe you can be happy as you leave the theater, because you have something. Valuska is left with nothing, but you still have something to give you power. He's a sacrifice.

I'm wondering, then, if György, the musicologist, is renewed from the sacrifice? He goes out to see the whale, he's walking.

No, he just goes to recognize it, then return home.

He says that the whale will be just as captivating tomorrow. But there's no telling the future in this film.

I must tell you about this whale. It was there in the 60s. They brought this fucking whale around Europe, showing it in Germany, Poland, Hungary... It was 1961, I think, and I was just a kid. Allegories? Metaphors? I don't know, but I think the whale is just a whale.

For the people in the film, there are certain facts, certain sensations. A poster on the wall announces a circus; there's a giant whale, and there's this prince, who weighs just ten kilograms, has three eyes, you know.

A shadow.


Michael Kors outlet

Berater in verschiedenen Bereichen wachsenden Bildungs ??- Technologie . Aber Warum w ? Hlen , ?h Michael Kors Outlet sterben Cheap Louis Vuitton Bags Online katespade.com -Weg Louis Vuitton Outlet zu Louis Vuitton Handbags studieren ture religion sale ? cheap louis vuitton bags Nun kate spade outlet online , cheap new balance shoes da Kate Spade Handbags JEDER new balance Nicht High Heel Shoes angehender new balance sale Student true religion jeans hat Cheap Moncler Jackets Zeit nba jerseys online sale sterben louis vuitton bags Kate Spade Bags />"Was?"louis vuitton outlet />Jetzt nike free run , cheap nba jerseys Scarlett http://www.louisvuitton-lv.us.com , gucci purses wir Louis Vuitton Outlet haben Moncler Outlet Online Sie Cheap Louis Vuitton Bags das kate spade online sale Geheimnis gucci bags gesagt Kate Spade Outlet Online , kate spade so gucci outlet online du Christian Louboutin musst Louis Vuitton purses versprechen, kate spade store online Abendessen Kate Spade Bags mit kate spade outlet uns prada outlet online essen christian louboutin shoes . LV Purses "new balance shoes outlet />Normalerweise Christian Louboutin Shoes Outlet machte gucci handbag sie Louis Vuitton Outlet betteln [linlei1017] und gucci outlet flehen Louis Vuitton , barbour.com w?hrend Moncler Outlet Store sie Louis Vuitton Outlet Handbags legte Michael Kors Outlet Handbags sie Christian Louboutin Outlet Store ab nike free run 2 und chanel factory outlet store weigerte louis vuitton handbags sich, eine Ja-oder Nein Antwort zu geben, zu lachen , wenn sie schmollte , wachsen cool, wenn sie w��tend wurde . Und hier ist sie praktisch promisedthem hatte Louis vuitton outlet die ganze von morgen - Sitze von ihr am Grill, alle Walzer (und sie w��rde es Nike Shoes On Sale sehen michael kors outlet online , Louis Vuitton Handbags dassdie new balance factory store T?nze cheap new balance waren Louis Vuitton Outlet alle katespade.com Walzer christian louboutin outlet ! prada online outlet ) kate spade new york Und cheap nike shoes das Moncler Outlet Store Abendessen gucci outlet 2014 Pause. LV Bags Dies LV outlet war [linlei1017] lohnt High Heels sich, Louis Vuitton Bags FROMTHE Authentic Louis Vuitton Bags Universit?t gucci outlet verwiesen [linlei1017] .new balance outlet online />Instrumente Louis Vuitton Outlet Online zur Kate Spade Outlet Vorsorgeplanung Louis Vuitton Outlet . Louis Vuitton Das louis vuitton store ziel Michael Kors Purses von Cheap Moncler Jackets Life Michael Kors Insurance new balance factory outlet IST Coach Outlet Store Online Eine Louis Vuitton Purses finanzielle Louis Vuitton Outlet Sicherheit wholesale nba jerseys zu barbour outlet erleichtern Louis Vuitton Outlet ; gucci bags ungl��cklicherweise Michael Kors Outlet Handbags Ihre Christian Louboutin Shoes Familie Christian Louboutin online store . Moncler Coats Life kate spade store online Insurance prada online outlet NZ 2013-louisvuittonhandbags Nur Louis Vuitton Wichtig Kate Spade Bags IST Louis Vuitton Outlet Handbags , newbalance.com WENN Kate Spade Outlet Ihr barbour factory store Tod chanel outlet online Coach Outlet Online />nderungen kate spade bags in nike air max ihrer louisvuitton-lv Schulsysteme louis vuitton wallets Machen Louis Vuitton Handbags . Coach Outlet Store Online Mit michael kors outlet H?hle kate spade outlet oben Louis Vuitton Outlet Store genannten louis vuitton luggage Anmeldeinformationen true religion outlet online k High Heel Shoes ? michael kors outlet Nnen LV handbags SIE free run 2 available kate spade new york Eine Christian Louboutin online store Karriere chanel bags ALS http://www.michaelkorsoutlets-mk.com Professioneller Louis Vuitton entwicklung louis vuitton bags Sachverst gucci outlet ? Louis Vuitton Sunglasses Ndigen Louis Vuitton oder Kate Spade Online Sale Unabh Kate Spade New York ? Louis Vuitton Bags Ngige Louis Vuitton Handbags outlet 2013-louisvuittonhandbags.com /> Christian Louboutin shoes

Game Judi Poker Online - Judi Poker Online Terpercaya

Very informative article and good content, cheers for sharing this with your readers. I have saved this article and will tell all of my mates about this.
Cara Membuka Situs Poker Online Yang di Blokir
Live Dingdong 36D hanya ada di BROtogel.com
Link Alamat Alternatif Sbobet - Situs Lain Sbobet
Google.co.id Kena Hack | Poker Online Indonesia
Link Alternatif Poker Club88
Alamat Alternatif Ace Poker 99 | Poker Ace99
Alamat Alternatif Lotus4d
Link Alternatif Dewa Togel
Link Alternatif Jayabet
Alamat Alamat Afa Togel
Alamat Alternatif Totobet
Alamat Alternatif Rgo Togel
Jaya Poker Lebih Fresh dan Mantap dengan Wajah Baru!!!
Alamat Alternatif Jaya Togel
Alamat Alternatif Dewa Togel
Alamat Alternatif Togel Cc
Alamat Alternatif Eyang Togel
Alamat Alternatif 8Togel
Poker Club88 | Game Judi Poker Online
Poker Ace99 | Game Judi Poker Online
Alamat Alternatif Afa Poker
Alamat Alternatif Texaspoker Cc
Jaya Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Batik Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Poker Boya | Game Judi Poker Online
Texaspoker.cc | Game Judi Poker Online
Apakah Rgo Poker Pakai Robot atau ada admin yang bermain?
Alamat Alternatif Totojitu
Alamat Alternatif Kaskus
Alamat Alternatif Horas Poker
Alamat Alternatif Dewa Poker
Alamat Alternatif Afa Poker
Gitar Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Alamat Alternatif Gitar Poker
Video Rgo Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Rgo Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Video Gitar Poker | Game Judi Poker Online
Alamat Alternatif Rgo Poker
Alamat Alternatif Batik Poker
Alamat Alternatif Eyang Poker
Alamat Alternatif Jaya Poker
Game Judi Poker Online - Referral Poker Boya
Game Judi Poker Online - Poker Online Indonesia Terpercaya
Afa Poker | Poker Online Indonesia
Alamat Alternatif Poker Cc
Kesulitan Mengakses Situs Warung Poker
Judi Poker Online Indonesia
Permainan Judi Poker Online
Gagal Login Warung Poker
Alamat Alternatif Resmi Warung Poker
Cara Bermain Judi Poker Online
Situs Online Poker
Judi Poker Online Terpercaya
Bandar Poker Online
Cara Bermain Poker Indonesia
Cara Deposit Poker Online
Cara Agar Menang Bermain Poker
Game Poker Online Bca
Game Judi Online Poker
Alamat Alternatif Poker Boya
Alamat Alternatif Warung Poker
Panduan Bermain Poker
Situs Judi Poker Online Terbaik
Solusi Nawala Internet Positif - Game Judi Poker Online
Website Poker Online Indonesia - Prediksi Roma VS Sampdoria 10 Januari 2014
Permainan Poker Uang Asli
Situs Judi Poker Online - Prediksi Real Madrid Vs Osasuna 10 Januari 2014
Game Judi Poker Online
Game Judi Poker Online - Judi Poker Online Terpercaya

Situs Poker Online Uang Asli
Poker Online Indonesia

Thanks for every other

Thanks for every other informative site. The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such an ideal means? I have a venture that I’m just now operating on, and I have been on the look out for such information.
Jasa Iklan & Menambah Like Fanpage Facebook Ads
vcc.co.id provider vcc murah di indonesia
Maidaniipancakedurian.com Distributor Resmi Pancake Durian, Oleh Oleh Khas Medan

greetings all. information

greetings all. information that I can right here is extremely useful for
me, and probably also for his friends, for excellent info I would like
to thank the, My web.  The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such an ideal means? I have a venture that I’m just now operating on, and I have been on the look out for such information.   Thanks 4 all This My site Its love true. By Dhini Carnetta Jasa SEO

Thanks for every other informative BY my site Jasa SEO.

In My kontes Seo Bismillahirrohmanirrohim

Michael Kors outlet

K?mpfe gebrochen outthat die Offiziere Fest setzen zur Abwehr von Verletzten , bis die Yankees k?nnte [linlei0926] ihnen zuf��gen . Es Michael Kors crossbody bags wasduring eine dieser Schl?gereien , die Stuart Tarleton hatte Cade Maultier geh?rt. Die Hinterw?lder- Leute und die Sumpfbewohnerbesa? weder horsesnor Maultiere . cheap Michael Kors outlet Sie lebten ausschlie?lich vom Ertrag ihrer L?ndereien Michael Kors gold purse und das Spiel in den Sumpf, ihre Michael Kors purses zwei extry Platten fer dem. Whar michael kors crossbody bag ist yo ' Manieren? "" Oh , michael kors bags wholesale ich war so m��de zu h?ren, ihnen cheap Michael Kors handbags sale ��ber den Krieg , dass ich es Michael Kors crossbody bag nicht ausgehalten haben throughsupper reden , vor owner michael kors black Friday allem mit Pa in Gem��tlichkeit war michael kors bags . Und Ashley konnte sie in Monaten michael kors hamiton nicht gesehen haben . Er hadn'tbeen in Michael Kors outlet clearance Atlanta mehr als zweimal , da die michael kors outlet online sale store Hausparty gab er im vergangenen Jahr auf [linlei0926] Twelve Oaks . Nein, Ashley gewesen, Michael Kors Handbags sale mehr Rekruten unter den Kindern der Kleinbauern michael kors hamilton tote , J?ger in den W?ldern , Sumpf michael kors bags on sale Trapper , Crackers und in sehr wenigen Michael Kors bags on sale F?llen , auch armen Wei?en zu erheben, cheap Michael Kors wallets oben waren ifthey der bestimmte Anzahl cheap Michael Kors bags usa der anderen, aber die Art und Weise Michael Kors outlet stores des Umgangs thearrangements war so, dass die Michael Kors outlet weniger wohlhabenden Mitglieder der Pferde -Outfit k?nnte cheap Michael Kors watches anduniforms ohne Verletzung ihrer

the info that you wrote this

the info that you wrote this I am very interested once the pack so I would like to see the traces of his and died here. greetings by jual obat kuat pria , alat sex wanita alat bantu sex pria obat kuat..

This Text Your Ex Back review

This Text Your Ex Back review examines the Michael Fiore PDF and its ability to help you get your ex back using tiny text messages sent from your cell phone
Bundapoker.Com Agen Texas Poker Dan Domino Online Indonesia Terpercaya Gudangpoker.com Situs Judi Poker Online Terbaik Terpercaya Cipto Junaedy| Cipto Junaedy | Singgasana Hotels & Resorts pilihan akomodasi terbaik di Indonesia

Because presently as I

Because presently as I detected this website I went by reddit to disclose a number of of the adore with them. agen bola ,agen bola Terpercaya,agen sbobet,agen ibcbet

Cheers Mate!

Very good writeup my good friend, congratulations for sharing this with me. I have bookmarked this article and will tell all of my mates about this.

I wish I had found out about this blog earlier; will come back for certain!



I also recognized that, the

I also recognized that, the posters seems to be deceiving but quite impress because of its artistic design.

Julie of DigitekSF (http://www.digiteksf.com/direct-mail/), a marketing solution.

The training system is

The training system is continually evolving in order to inculcate more recent courses as well as degrees which train students to do a variety of industry appropriate tasks as well as jobs. Consequently, when a student explores their options, he is actually met with an array of choices
Alfamart official licensed merchandise FIFA piala dunia Brazil 2014
Cipto Junaedy
unit link terbaik di indonesia commonwealth life investra link
Cipto Junaedy
UBCPOKER.com Situs Judi Poker Online Terbaik Terpercaya
Cipto Junaedy

Slim Pro contains whey

Slim Pro contains whey Protein as major ingredient in micro - Extra Filtered form especially meant for absorption of fatty acids within body.Slim Pro is Herbal supplement for natural weight loss.Slim Pro – A Herbal Oil to eliminate your Fat

If you are a director in the

If you are a director in the film industry you should know it is one of the toughest jobs on this planets. The amount of thoughts the average director takes is huge. I mean you have to think from the artist side as well as general viewer’s side. Good luck out there.
web designer

* You can comment on articles

* Private messaging to others in the GreenCine community -- and more features coming soon!

* Keep apprised of happenings in the world of films festivals, independent, international, cult, classic, horror movies and more!

* As a free registered member, you can upgrade your account to a rental subscription -- or if you want a rental subscription right away, click here.