Rory Kennedy: Disturbing the Ghosts of Abu Ghraib

interviewed by Michael Guillen -- February-2007

Rory Kennedy's probing hbo documentary Ghosts of Abu Ghraib is now out on dvd. As David Courier wrote, introducing the film when it premiered at Sundance in January, Kennedy "explores how, given the right circumstances, typical boys and girls next door can commit atrocious acts of violence.... The now-infamous photos that emerged from Abu Ghraib represent only the tip of the iceberg, pointing to systemic abuse from Guantanamo Bay to Afghanistan and beyond. These photos have come to redefine the United States - once considered a bastion of human rights - as a principal proponent of torture. Have we blurred the distinction between ourselves and terrorists in ways that will haunt our country throughout history? Powerful, restrained, and fiercely compelling, Ghosts of Abu Ghraib demands that we examine our conscience as a nation."

Bay Area audiences have had two unique opportunities to catch Ghosts of Abu Ghraib in an Oscar-qualifying albeit limited theatrical release. It ran for three days at the Roxie Film Center and then was screened at Fort Mason's Cowell Theater for members of the World Affairs Council. In attendance at the World Affairs Council screening, Rory Kennedy took time to talk with me about her disturbingly poignant documentary.

 


Watching Ghosts of Abu Ghraib, I noted three or four instances in which the military police - to qualify the reality of their being put into the position of prison guards - likened their experience unto movies; either The Shining, Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome or Apocalypse Now. That, in and of itself, is not anything new. For quite some time, people have questioned this popular tendency to describe reality as being "like a movie." But what intrigues me is that there is also currently a popular trend in the horror genre that indulges what is being called "torture porn." Perhaps it is a cultural zeitgeist reflecting our fear of torture in torturous times? Notwithstanding, the trend concerns me. Your documentary impressed me because it seemed to balance against the fictionalized voyeurism of torture porn with some hands-on information about real government-sanctioned torture. Do you have any thoughts about the value of documentary as a corrective or instructive ameliorative against fictionalized torture porn?

I'll tell you an anecdote: Tony Lagouranis - who is one of the characters that we interviewed in the film - was an interrogator at Abu Ghraib but was also on a mobile unit that traveled throughout Iraq. He interrogated people at a number of different facilities throughout the country. What he said was that there were a lot of interrogators who he worked with who said that they got their ideas of how to interrogate through television.

Television really does have a significant impact in terms of having a material effect. If you go to Iraq and somebody's torturing somebody like they torture them on 24, it's obviously inspired by that television show. The other thing that happens in some of these more fictitious accounts is they're not reflecting the real reality of the situation. For example, I think what happens in a lot of these TV shows is there's a situation where there's a bus full of kids and, if you interrogate somebody, they're going to get the information to save the children. So be it. If you've got to torture somebody a little bit to get the information, it's worth it to save that busload of kids. So when people think of torture, they think, "Wow. If we can prevent another 9/11 by torturing somebody a little bit, then that's okay."

That's just not the reality. The reality is what Tony Lagouranis talks about which is they say, "Listen, we think there was an IED attack and it's somebody who did it in a black Opal." They round up everybody, 200 people, who were driving black Opals and they torture all of them. At least 199 of them are totally innocent and probably 200 of them are, right? So they treat them horrifically and there's no information that's gained. We have to deal with the realities of what torture is and I don't think these TV shows do it justice - or probably these horror films, though I don't really watch horror films that often.

I've sampled torture porn movies like Saw, Hostel and Wolf Creek - because I'm trying to understand why audiences are attracted to these movies. I suspect it is because in these films the possibility of torture is presented as something coming from without, from the other, from foreigners, which is to imply the possibility that Americans feel comfortable claiming the mantle of victimization. Your documentary is powerful because you've laid out that, in truth, the fear is going in the wrong direction and that it is our government policy that has made it easy for American military personnel to torture Iraqi civilians.

Right.

But Ghosts of Abu Ghraib is not just a study in finger pointing. Or, where it points most of all is to the darkness within. Thus your film is in the unique vanguard of exploring the psychology of why people torture. You bookend the events at Abu Ghraib with archival footage from Dr. Stanley Milgram's 1961 Yale "Obedience" study during which test subjects were encouraged to inflict pain upon others. Your documentary quotes Dr. Milgram's somber conclusion: "The results, as I observed them in the laboratory, are disturbing. If in this study an anonymous experimenter could successfully command adults to subdue a 50-year- old man and force on him painful electric shocks against his protests, one can only wonder what government, with its vastly greater authority and prestige, can command of its subjects." To achieve an exploration of yet one further example of Hannah Arendt's well-known "banality of evil", and how authority-respecting individuals will follow commands to torture others, your documentary employs a plurality of voices. When you were conceiving and designing the documentary, did you think you would achieve this variety of viewpoint?

I didn't. I didn't expect to be able to get access to that many of the soldiers. I was very happy to be able to speak with them. I know a lot of people are hissing at John Yoo in the documentary but it took a lot of courage for him to be a part of this film. His perspective is important in understanding where the Administration is coming from. I was happy to be able to talk to someone within the Administration who was there at the time in the Justice Department to understand where they were coming from. Then, of course, getting access to the detainees was a challenge logistically and otherwise but they add a dimension to the film that's enormously important. They provide a perspective we really haven't heard from before and a dimension that balances out the film overall.

Comments

the info that you wrote this

the info that you wrote this I am very interested once the pack so I would like to see the traces of his and died here. greetings by jual obat kuat pria , alat sex wanita alat bantu sex pria obat kuat..

marc jacobs watches

louis vuitton italy
jordan school district
purses louis vuitton
jordans kids
louis vuitton dog collar
pink louis vuitton
Authentic Retro Jordans
insanity pure cardio
who is the designer of juicy couture
Air Jordan Shoes
designer handbags for less
fake oakleys cheap free shipping
all jordan shoes ever released
ray ban sun glasses
jordan 11
louis vuitton uk handbags women
True Religion Men's Jeans
black true religion jeans
ray ban parts
sabres jerseys
Air Jordan Six Rings
results of insanity workout
louis vuitton.com
jordan retros 10
red kiss shoes
true religion ricky big t
oakley online
oakley a wire
ray ban knockoffs
hermes birkin orange
louis vuitton baby bags
louis vuitton swimwear
Retro 11 Low
jordan retro 13
louis vuitton hoodies
chi camo flat iron
hermes franca
louis vuitton designer
ray ban jackie ohh
jordan 18 for sale
fountain pen mont blanc
jordan retro 1 og
cheap louis vuitton sunglasses
orange toms
toms shoes coupons
true religion jeans women
insanity workout what is it
Air Jordan Fusion 9
ray ban rx sunglasses
louis vuitton watches for women
ralph lauren purple label
trip to jordan
fendi bags online store
true religion hoodie
louis vuitton repair
oakley pitboss
jordan women
abercrombie bedding
oakley prescription glasses dealers
insanity workout results
second hand mont blanc pens
oakley plank
new jordan shoes
louis vuitton damier graphite
louboutin london
true religion shirts
insane workouts
ray ban wayfarer optical
Jordan 6 Retro 2014
hollister malaia perfume
silky straight hair
abercrombie & fitch coupons
newest jordans sneakers 2014
louis vuitton manhattan
louboutin shoes sale
christian louboutin bibi
outlet true religion jeans
Bred 11s
jerseys wholesale
celine designer
fendi red bag
hermes saddles
louis vuitton money clip wallet
women jordans shoes
jordan shoes on sale
hermes men shoes
wholesale toms shoes
christian louboutin red soles
true religion shop online
louis vuitton kanye west shoes
true religion black friday
air jordan 4 docrnbecher
where to buy cheap toms
louisvuitton.com - louis vuitton international page
23 is Back
Toms Shoes Stores
mlb jersey china
shoes red soles
i chi flat iron jcpenney
oakley for women
louis vuitton multicolor
all jordan shoes ever released
Ralph Lauren Outlet Mall
nike jordans women shoes
chi zebra flat iron
denim ralph lauren
hollister swimwear
abercrombie kids outlet
ralph lauren winter coat
air jordan alpha 1
a&f abercrombie
abercrombie perfume 8
Air Jordan Concord 2011
Really Cheap Oakley Sunglasses
jordan retro 6 champagne
jordan flight 1
louis vuitton shirts for men
Jordan Retro 8 Black
ray bam
true religion official website
trek mont blanc
oakley glasses frames oakley eyewear
true religion jeans petite
wholesale chi flat iron
christian louboutin shoes for women
cheap china wholesale jerseys
blue glitter toms
jordans sneakers
hollister england
toms bracelet
how good is insanity workout
louis vuitton odeon pm
where to buy toms cheap
true religion jeans store
hermes key ring
uk juicy couture
louis vuitton leather bags
pink jordans for girls
insanity workout chart
toms outlet north facet pink
lv outlet
mont blanc boutique toronto
ray bans sunglasses for men
cheap jordan shoes for sale under $50
cheap oakley sunglasses discount oakley sunglasses
new jordans 2014 releases
air jordan retro 4
ralph lauren wallets
louis vuitton umbrella
Cheap Ray Ban Glasses
juicy couture glasses
white glitter toms
white jordans
Jordan Retro 13 Shoes
juicy coutore
louis vuitton paris
air jordan 5 black grape
louis vuitton watches for men
abercrombie and fitch bags
High Quality Louis Vuitton
True Religion Brand Jeans Sale
mont blanc ski resort
kids ray bans
hermes usa online
toms where to buy
louis vuitton men wallet
air jordans 1
air jordan 5
ray ban eye glasses
toms shoes outlet store online
Ralph Lauren Tropical Comforter
air jordan 5 laney
mens louis vuitton shoes
louis vuitton canada outlet
mens louis vuitton wallet
jordan women shoes
toms shoe company
true religion women jeans
louis vuitton coin purse
mont blanc nyc
true religion sale hoodies
best workout videos
louis vuitton artsy
true religion flare jeans
Jordan 11 for Sale
christian louboutin shoes discount
jordan sneakers online
Air Jordan Retro 4
oakley warehouse
jordan cleats release dates
abercrombie site
louis vuitton international
chi straightening irons
louis vuitton t shirts
ray ban vintage
louis vuitton shoes women
wholesale ray bans
ray ban catalogue
hermes birkin sizes
chi flat
black sparkle toms
Tom Shoes Outlet with Free Shipping
insanity home workout
toms com/returns
all jordan shoes in order
air jordan shoes history
louis vuitton baby clothes
ray ban sale 19.99
jordan release dates 2014
louis vuitton neverfull sizes
ray ban wiki
true religion jeans uk
ray ban rb3025 aviator large metal
ray ban sunglasses warranty
insanity workout home
fountain pens mont blanc
religion clothing uk
insanity workout for sale cheap
hermes mens shoes
abercrombie modeling
oakley si ballistic m frame 2.0
who is christian louboutin
insanity workout dvds
louis vuitton hoodie
jordans kids shoes
ralph lauren fashion
order jordans online
jordan retro 6 release dates
religion clothing london
jordans release dates 2013
toms factory outlet online
shop mont blanc
ralph lauren polo shirts for men
the new jordans
Ray Ban Discount Outlet
true religion jacket
louis vuitton sunglasses for men
chi hair products official website
jordans 11 cool grey
Ray Ban Eyeglasses at Discount Prices
mont blanc route
oakley forces
hollister tshirt
fendi doctor bag
ray ban coupon
celine online shopping
abercrombie discount
jordan retro 1 retro high
isanity workout
mont blanc organizer
polo ralph lauren kids
ray ban rb3387
tour de mont blanc france
release dates for jordans
true religion outlet canada
Air Jordan Retro 6
juicy couture neiman marcus
baby ralph lauren
hollister clothing stores
toms coupon code free shipping 2011
Faux Louis Vuitton Wallets
oakley jacket
buy jerseys online
Real Jordan for Sale
insanity shaun t
black and yellow jordans
louis vuitton china wholesale
jordan collection
louis vuitton jewelry
beach body insanity schedule
hollister for men
abercrombie employment
hermes honolulu
jordan 13 for sale
michael jordan shoes official website
louis vuitton shop
louis vuitton toronto
true religion
louis vuitton outlet locations
true religion jeans men
louboutin leopard
authentic louis vuitton speedy 30
ray ban polarized
ray ban aviator polarized
cheetah print toms
Oakley Eyewear
louis vuitton key chain
louis vuitton t shirts
louis vuitton sunglasses millionaire
juicy couture outlet online store
best price chi flat iron
nike jordan
ray ban price
louis vuitton leather
true religion jeans australia
louis vuitton damier ebene speedy 30
ralph lauren the big pony collection
mont blanc writing instruments
sale toms shoes
where can you buy toms in canada
ray ban clubmaster sunglasses
jordan 6 infrared
girl jordans shoes for sale
jordan xi
true religion jeans jacket
ray ban rb4147
celine purse online
hollister beach
cordless chi flat iron
gold ray ban aviators
air jordan retro shoes
true religion factory outlet
louis vuitton handbag prices
ralph lauren baby girl
Air Jordan 2014
Jordan Release Dates 2014
juicy couture shopstyle
louis vuitton trevi pm
Jordan 6 Rings Release Date
zapatos jordan
Jordan Shoes for Kids
true religion jeans outlet store
chi straightener on sale
toms river township
true religion size chart
wholesale juicy couture tracksuits
true religion prices
jordan true flight kids
ralph lauren perfume for men
jordan cleats
cheap jerseys online free shipping
chi hair curling iron
nordstrom juicy couture handbags
red carpet shoes
true religion skirt
preowned louis vuitton
air jordan 11 gamma blue
old school jordans
oakley apparel
true religion logo
cheap authentic louis vuitton
mont blanc marathon
abercrombie coupon code
ralph lauren kids jacket
louis vuitton jeans for men
true religion footwear
ralph lauren femme
true religion apparel inc
petra jordan tourism
true religion jeans nyc
louis vuitton mens wallets
ray ban wayfarer large
Buy Retro Jordan 11
birkins hermes
fendi messenger bag
ray ban wayfare
true religion schuhe
coupons for chi flat iron
air jordan for sale
toms the shoes
jordan fashions
abercrombie scarf
tomsshoes.com
true religion perfume review
hello kitty toms
juicy couture laptop sleeve
shoes christian louboutin
jordan spieth
toms sale canada
hermes bearn wallet
nike jordans for kids
womens jordans for sale
iron flat chi
Foamposite Release Dates 2014
jordan true flight men's basketball shoe
insanity classes
oakley hat
louis vuitton ipad case
toms shoes canada sale
toms shoes one for one
hollister address
true religion america
abercrombie us site
oakley monster pup
jordans air
louis vuitton stencil
Jordan Retro 11 Release Date
cheap toms online free shipping
chi flat iron official site
louis vuitton card holder
nfl jerseys from china
louis vuitton men sunglasses
ray ban frame
wholesale abercrombie and fitch
jordan 17 copper
polo ralph lauren outlet online
hollister shop
louis vuitton us
oakley prescription glasses retailers
Toms Shoes Stores
louis vuitton delightful pm
louis vuitton knockoffs
Cheap Wholesale Jordan Shoes
new jordan releases dates 2014
true religion sunglasses
chi air 1 flat iron
louis vuitton dons
louis vuitton shoes for women 2014
abercrombie jacket
Jordan Shoes for Kids
jordan retro 1 release date
juicy couture sweatsuits
rare air jordans
ralph lauren sleepwear
black toms
ray ban 8307
louis vuitton key chain
ray ban wafers
hermes canvas bag
jordan 8 playoffs
wholesale jerseys china free shipping
louis vuitton polo
High Quality Louis Vuitton
sparkly toms
cheap abercrombie fitch
louis vuitton speedy 25 price
red bottom shoes
air jordan release dates foot locker
newest louis vuitton handbags 2013
mont blanc eyeglasses
chi volumizing iron
ray ban polarized sunglasses
chi
jordan 6 rings
louis vuitton alma
Jumpman 23 Release Dates Sneakers
insane workout videos
truereligionjeans
ray ban wayfarer cheap
abercrombie fitch canada
ray ban rb2132 polarized
buy celine bags
louis vuitton shawl
louis vuitton neverfull gm
80 % Off Ray Bans
ray ban 3293
Jordan Spizikes for Sale
jordan release dates 2014-2015
religion clothing line
louis vuitton mens clothing
fake ray ban aviators
oakley gascan lens
speedy louis vuitton
hermes france
louis vuitton
ray ban sunglasses usa
true religion shorts
red ralph lauren polo
abercrombie for kids
insanity workout training
baby jordans for girls
toms shoes
true religion jean sale
chi products reviews
true religion jeans
ray ban wayfarer rb2132
Air Jordans 2
Christian Louboutin Neiman Marcus

if you are looking for poonam

if you are looking for
poonam pandey hot images then this is the wonderfull for all your need.

An impressive share! I've

An impressive share! I've just forwarded this onto a friend who has been doing a little homework on this. And he in fact bought me lunch because I found it for him... lol. So let me reword this.... Thanks for the meal!! But yeah, thanks for spending the time to talk about this subject here on your website.

free rental agreement nc

Shameful Really

Can't believe these things are still used in today's world :/.

This Page
Check This Out
While Reading This

Figuring out how considerably

Figuring out how considerably excess weight to shed is a key aspect of that setting up.If you want to lose weight rapid, consume Slim Pro daily for 24 days and see the change in you. have a nice figure and body with Slim Pro.Buy Slim Pro –To decrease your fatness

* You can comment on articles

* Private messaging to others in the GreenCine community -- and more features coming soon!

* Keep apprised of happenings in the world of films festivals, independent, international, cult, classic, horror movies and more!

* As a free registered member, you can upgrade your account to a rental subscription -- or if you want a rental subscription right away, click here.